The whole issue of “Santa Claus” is problematic, at least for a Christian. While we eschew following culture if it impedes our spiritual witness, we sometimes allow ourselves some slippage. Most people could say that if I don’t like the myth of Santa Claus, well, okay, just don’t use it. You might consider the whole idea as just a benign fun part of Christmas. But is it really as harmless as you might think?
Now, first, there’s the thing about his name. What is it really? Saint Nicholas, St. Nick, Pere Noël, Kris Kringle, or simply Santa? Then there’s this thing about what kind of person he is. Is he normal human size or is he an elf? (And is that even socially acceptable, for is an elf a dwarf, or in the current vernacular, a “tiny person”?) And are all those elves, er, excuse me, tiny persons part of forced labor, and are there others living in other parts of the world? What we know about the supposed origin of Santa, is a poorly documented history of a man called Nicholas of Myra (in what is now Turkey), who was at some point canonized by the Roman Catholic Church as well as the Greek Orthodox Church. Protestants discount such canonization, believing that all born again Christians are saints. (For instances of this terminology see Romans 16:2, Ephesians 4:12, and 5:3.) It was reported that his parents died, leaving him with considerable wealth, which he used to help the needy. Since the first written accounts were done long after his demise, the accuracy of such reports is uncertain and, in such remote telling of history, various other tales and exploits were added.
Since the myth of Santa Claus does not have any connection with the birth of Christ, why was the evening of December 24th selected? We need to note that few Christians believe that Jesus was born on December 24/25th, and many have come to the conclusion that September 11th was the more accurate time of his birth. (But that is another discussion entirely.) However, the date was not picked arbitrarily, but, instead, was selected because of the Winter Solstice at that time which was a huge pagan festival. Saturnalia as it was called, was a worship of the god Saturn. This was a time of unbridled debauchery, feasting, and pagan influences. While the Roman celebration of Saturnalia is part of the equation, the ancient Norsemen worshiped their god Oden, an old man with a long white beard, who rode through the night sky in a sleigh, drawn by his eight-legged horse Sleipnir who was said to be able to jump to high levels. (Does this remind you of reindeer?) Other pagan traditions that connect with the Santa version of Christmas are the colors of red and white on his suit, the Yule log, mistletoe, the giving of presents, the decorated tree and many others are all some of the early pagan influences.
Two American authors did much to promulgate Santa Claus as we perceive him today. The Dutch had brought their traditions when they came to New Amsterdam, a.k.a. New York. This time Santa Claus was described as an elf, smoking a clay pipe. Washington Irving embellished this story in 1809. Later Clement C. Moore penned his eponymous poem which came to be called “The Night Before Christmas”.
These pagan roots might be enough to shun the Santa Claus fiasco, but there are two more reasons why I really don’t like this farce. It is blatantly inaccurate at best and is definitely unkind. Do we really teach our children that if you are good you’ll get gifts, but those who aren’t don’t get them? Even as a young child I realized that there were some children who got little to nothing for Christmas, while those from affluent families got heaps. What a stigma to toss on a child! Is it just a parental threat tactic?
The last reason I have such great objections to Santa Claus, is that it puts the parent into a position of lying to their child and later having to redact it. What does this say about whatever else you tell them? Children are literal thinkers and if their trusted parent tells them there is a Santa Claus, the child is likely to believe them. Have you ever noticed how you have to be careful in a group of children and dare not say there is no Santa Claus? And when the child does find out it was all a silly joke played on them, they are hurt. The implications of this for Christian parents is even more critical. They can scarcely tell the child that Santa Claus is real but later refute it, but at the same time try to teach the story of Jesus’ birth and His wonderful gift of salvation for everyone who believes. Will they not give as much credence to the myth as they do to the reality? If reading “The Night Before Christmas” is a must part of the Christmas Eve traditions, but the readings on Christ’s birth from the Bible are not, which will seem of greater importance? An interesting example of that lie , intermingled with the truth happened a couple of nights ago. My husband was randomly scrolling through some of the Christmas videos on television, when he came across one that looked promising. Within five minutes of watching, the little girl in the movie said that she would “pray to Santa” for a miracle. This is the kind of mess the use of Santa Claus makes with children.
So, what are we to make out of all this? I hardly think that we’re going to change the whole December event. Each person and family need to consider how to deal with this. Many have chosen to avoid any of the aspects of the season, while others opt to retain some. But do we throw out the baby with the bathwater so to speak. Can we redeem the holiday from its wretched past? That is what others have sought to do in centuries past as well as some who had nothing to do with the festivities. Philippians 2:12,13 may give some insight into this since we are told to work out our salvation with fear and trembling. While this does not infer that we have to do anything to earn our salvation, or that we make decisions on how that is to happen, the verses indicate that there is some intentionality to our service to God. We do not just go along with the way society represents Santa Claus, but think about how you approach this and all the other aspects of Christmas. Ultimately our goal is to bring honor to God, and this may be one way to demonstrate the God who gave us the greatest gifts. But as for my household, you won’t see any inflatable plastic Santa on our lawn. And if one should appear, I’ll pull its plug!



